Form Over Function? A Look Into Hardware Placement on Cabinet Doors

Deciding where to place knobs and pulls on cabinet doors can already be a nerve-wracking process, especially when you have a mix of hardware in the kitchen. We have found that by selecting the right knobs or pulls can definitely transform the look and feel of your space, while also making your day-to-day kitchen tasks easier. If you’re pondering whether to choose cabinet knobs or cabinet pulls for your new kitchen cabinet doors, keep reading!

We recently had 2 kitchen projects in which our clients were asking themselves the age old question: "Form Over Function?" This post will break down the differences, help you explore design and functional considerations, and guide you toward making a selection that suits your style and lifestyle.

So lets explore both options:

Knobs vs. Pulls: The Basic Differences

Kitchen Cabinet Knobs

• Design: Knobs are typically small, rounded, or decorative pieces that attach to the cabinet door or drawer with a single screw.

• Placement: Generally placed in the upper corner of a cabinet door (or near the corner of a drawer) for easy opening.

• Operation: You grab and pull from a single contact point, which can work well for lighter doors and drawers.

Kitchen Cabinet Pulls

• Design: Pulls often have a bar-like shape or a curved handle and attach to the cabinet or drawer with two or more screws, offering a more substantial grip.

• Placement: Horizontal on drawers, and vertical or sometimes angled on cabinet doors.

• Operation: You can wrap your entire hand around a pull, making them a popular choice for heavier drawers, large cabinet doors, and universal design.

---

Some Points for overall Style Considerations

1. Overall Kitchen Aesthetic

• Traditional or Classic: Knobs, especially round or intricately detailed ones, work wonderfully in classic or farmhouse kitchens. They can also be found in various vintage styles.

• Contemporary or Modern: Sleek and minimal pulls complement modern cabinetry. Bar pulls or streamlined rectangular designs often add a sophisticated touch to flat-panel cabinets.

2. Visual Impact

• Subtle Accents: Knobs add a subtle hint of style without drawing too much attention. They can either blend seamlessly or provide a small pop of color if you choose decorative finishes.

• Bold Statements: Pulls can create a focal point in your kitchen, especially if you select a substantial size or an eye-catching finish (e.g., matte black, brushed gold, or polished chrome).

3. Mix and Match

• Combining Styles: Some homeowners pair knobs on cabinet doors with pulls on drawers. This contrast can add visual interest and keep the overall look cohesive if you stick to the same finish or design family.

• Versatility of Finishes: Both knobs and pulls come in a variety of finishes, such as brushed nickel, brass, chrome, black, and even colored ceramics or acrylic. Opt for a finish that complements your existing lighting fixtures, appliances, or decorative details.

---

Tips for Making the Right Choice

1. Assess Functionality First
   If you have young children or older adults in your household, choose hardware that’s easy to grip and unlikely to cause accidental bumps or catches on clothing. In those cases, consider pulls with smooth edges or larger knob designs.

2. Experiment with Samples
   Don’t be shy about buying a few different hardware styles before fully committing. Attach sample knobs or pulls to one or two cabinets to see how they look and feel in real life. Lighting and the way you move in your kitchen can impact which style feels more natural.

3. Consider Cabinet Door Style

• Shaker Cabinets: Both knobs and pulls work well. A mix of knobs for doors and pulls for drawers is a timeless choice.

• Flat-Front Cabinets: Sleek, linear pulls often enhance the modern vibe of flat-front styles.

• Raised-Panel Cabinets: Ornate pulls or classic round knobs frequently complement traditional raised-panel doors.

4. Match Finishes with Existing Fixtures
   Coordinate your cabinet hardware finishes with faucets, lighting, and appliances for a cohesive design. This doesn’t mean everything has to be identical, but consistency can create a harmonious kitchen atmosphere.

Conclusion

Choosing between knobs vs. pulls may seem like a small detail, but it can make a big difference in your kitchen’s appearance and functionality. Knobs tend to be a simpler, budget-friendly option that blends well with traditional or classic aesthetics. Pulls, on the other hand, lend themselves to easy handling and modern, streamlined looks, especially for larger drawers or doors.

Ultimately, the “right choice” comes down to finding the perfect balance between form and function. Think about how you use your kitchen, the style you’re aiming for, and your budget. By evaluating the factors mentioned above — from design and comfort to installation and maintenance — you’ll be well on your way to selecting cabinet hardware that not only enhances your new kitchen cabinets but also brings joy and efficiency to your daily cooking routine.